A starter for a 2005 Honda Element typically costs about $120 to $350, depending on whether you choose aftermarket, remanufactured, or OEM-new units, and whether you buy new or used. Installation, if done by a shop, adds additional labor costs.
The 2005 Element uses a 2.4-liter engine, and prices can vary by supplier, warranty, core charges, and regional availability. This article summarizes current typical prices and shopping options to help you estimate total costs.
Prices by type
Prices vary by what you buy: original equipment (OEM) vs aftermarket, new vs remanufactured, and whether the unit is new or refurbished. The following ranges reflect common market prices from major parts retailers and aftermarket suppliers as of 2026.
- New OEM starter: typically in the range of $180–$360. Prices can vary by dealer and part number; some retailers run promotions that bring the price down.
- New aftermarket starter: commonly $120–$230. These are built by third-party manufacturers and often include warranty.
- Remanufactured/rebuilt starter: usually $100–$180, sometimes with a core charge that is refunded after you return the old unit.
- Used/ salvage-yard starter: often $40–$120, depending on condition and mileage. Used parts carry a higher risk of shorter remaining life.
Note: core charges, warranty terms, and availability can shift price; always verify current pricing with a retailer or mechanic before purchase.
Where to buy
Shopping options include major auto parts chains, online retailers, and salvage yards. The right source depends on your budget, warranty expectations, and whether you want in-person pickup or home delivery.
- AutoZone, Advance Auto Parts, O'Reilly Auto Parts: national chains that commonly stock both OEM and aftermarket starters; many offer 1-year or longer warranties on new and reman units.
- RockAuto and CARiD: online retailers with wide price ranges and delivery options, useful for comparing multiple brands quickly.
- OEM dealers: for authentic parts or vehicle-specific variants; prices tend to be higher but come with manufacturer-backed warranties.
- Salvage yards: typically the lowest prices for used starters but limited guarantees; ensure the unit is tested or return options exist.
When buying, check the warranty length, core policy, return window, and compatibility with your exact engine and model year. The Element's 2.4L engine had several revisions, so double-check part numbers or ask a parts specialist to confirm compatibility.
Installation and total cost
You can replace the starter yourself if you have mechanical experience; otherwise, a shop can handle it. Labor costs depend on your location and the shop's hourly rate.
DIY vs professional installation
Consider your tools, space, and safety. The starter is mounted on the engine block and requires access from around the engine bay. If you are comfortable with basic hand tools and car jacks, you may accomplish it; otherwise a professional installation is advised.
Estimated labor scenarios and costs help you gauge total outlay. The following breakdown covers common cases you might encounter when scheduling service.
- Labor time: about 1.5 to 3 hours for a typical installation, though access on the Element can vary by model year and engine layout.
- Labor rate: commonly $80–$120 per hour in many regions; high-cost urban areas can be higher.
- Total installed cost: roughly $160–$500, depending on the chosen starter price and labor rate. A high-end OEM or reman unit plus labor could approach the upper end of this range.
Always request a written estimate that itemizes parts and labor, and confirm whether a diagnostic check is included if the vehicle exhibits starting issues beyond a simple starter failure (such as battery or wiring problems).
Summary
For a 2005 Honda Element, expect starter prices to range from approximately $120 on the low end for a new aftermarket unit up to $350 or more for an OEM-new part. Remanufactured and used options can save money but carry greater risk. Labor to install usually adds about $100–$350 depending on shop rates and vehicle access. Always verify compatibility with your exact engine and check current prices at multiple retailers to lock in the best deal. If you’d like, I can pull current prices from specific stores you trust.
In short, a careful shopping approach—balancing price, warranty, and reliability—helps ensure you get a starter that fits your 2005 Honda Element without overpaying. A final price will depend on your chosen source and whether you opt for DIY installation or professional service.