Yes. The 2016 Toyota Highlander is generally considered a solid used-SUV choice, offering reliability, a comfortable ride, and strong resale value, though it lacks some newer tech and has a few aging components.
In this article, we examine how the 2016 Highlander performs in reliability, safety, and ownership costs, how it stacks up against rivals, and what buyers should check when considering a used example.
Performance and powertrains
Key details about the engines, transmission, and overall driving character, including what buyers should expect in everyday use.
Engines and transmission
The 2016 Highlander offered two engines: a 2.7-liter four-cylinder and a 3.5-liter V6, both paired with a six-speed automatic. The four-cylinder produces about 185 horsepower, while the V6 makes about 270 horsepower and 248 lb-ft of torque. Front-wheel drive was standard with optional all-wheel drive on most trims. The V6 is the preferred option for acceleration, highway performance, and towing, while the four-cylinder is adequate for city driving and offers better fuel economy.
In daily driving, the Highlander delivers a smooth ride and a quiet cabin, with adequate power from the V6 and reasonable efficiency from the four-cylinder. Real-world fuel economy varies by configuration and driving style but typically lands in the mid-teens to mid-20s mpg depending on engine and drivetrain.
Reliability and ownership costs
What owners and reviewers say about long-term reliability, upkeep, and total cost of ownership for the 2016 Highlander.
Pros
Here are the positives that commonly attract buyers to a 2016 Highlander:
- Reliability reputation and strong resale value
- Capable V6 with adequate towing power
- Spacious three-row interior and solid cargo space
- Comfortable ride and quiet cabin
Overall, Toyota’s reputation for durability often translates into favorable ownership costs and high mileage potential for well-maintained 2016 Highlanders.
Cons
On the downside, consider these potential drawbacks:
- Older interior tech and infotainment compared with newer SUVs
- Six-speed automatic is not as refined as newer eight-speed units
- Some models may have higher tire wear or suspension wear with mileage
These issues don’t affect every vehicle, but they’re common talking points when evaluating a used 2016 Highlander. It’s important to verify a complete maintenance history and check for any open recalls.
Safety and ratings
Safety performance and the availability of driver-assistance features on the 2016 Highlander, including how it fared in major tests.
IIHS and NHTSA results
In overall safety testing, the 2016 Highlander earned favorable ratings from IIHS and NHTSA, with solid protection in many crash scenarios. Higher trims offered optional safety tech such as blind-spot monitoring and rear cross-traffic alert, depending on packages and equipment. As an older model, it lacks some of the latest safety features found in newer vehicles.
Always confirm the specific vehicle’s safety equipment and recall history before purchase.
What to look for when buying a used 2016 Highlander
Before buying a used Highlander from this era, perform a thorough check of maintenance history, recalls, and the condition of key systems.
Checklist for prospective buyers
Use this list to assess the condition and history of a 2016 Highlander you’re considering.
- Complete service history with regular maintenance and any major repairs documented
- All recalls and campaigns completed, including airbag and fuel-system-related items
- Transmission shifts smoothly with no shudder or slipping in city and highway driving
- Brakes, steering, suspension, and tires in good condition with no unusual noises
- All power equipment and infotainment systems functioning correctly
- Minimal signs of rust or frame damage; vehicle has a clean title and no flood damage
A verified maintenance history and a pre-purchase inspection by a qualified technician can help you avoid expensive repairs and ensure long-term peace of mind.
How it stacks up against rivals
Compared with its midsize three-row SUV competitors, the 2016 Highlander generally offers better reliability and resale value, plus a comfortable interior. Competitors like the Honda Pilot, Ford Explorer, and Nissan Pathfinder offer different strengths in things like interior tech, towing capacity, or ride refinement, so the best choice depends on what you value most.
Bottom line and buying tips
For family-oriented buyers who prioritize reliability and space, the 2016 Highlander remains a strong option in the used market.
However, it’s older enough that you should expect to forgo some modern tech and advanced safety features that are common on newer models. A careful inspection and a thorough review of the vehicle’s maintenance and recall history are essential steps in the buying process.
Summary
The 2016 Toyota Highlander is generally regarded as a practical, durable choice in the used SUV segment. It blends a quiet ride, ample room, and Toyota’s well-earned reputation for reliability, with the trade-off of older tech and a four-cylinder engine that may feel underpowered in some situations compared with the V6. For many buyers, it remains a good year to buy if you prioritize longevity and resale value, provided you verify the vehicle’s maintenance and recall status.